When do you re-open in the spring?
Our soft opening is typically the last week of March, and our full opening is the first weekend in April. Check out our store schedule for exact times during the season.
Where are you located?
Our address is 57 Picketty Ruff Walk, Fire Island Pines. Our front entrance faces the Harbor on the west side, just north of the Blue Whale.
Do you do Phone Orders/ call in grocery list?
We take phone orders for large bulk delivery orders, such as cases of beer, water, seltzers, mixers, etc. We do not take small personal shopping orders over the phone.
Do you have bags?
We do have reusable bags and paper bags for purchase at checkout. We recommend bringing your bags or utilizing our bag drop/recycle near the registers. Unfortunately, due to health codes, we cannot give out the recycled/2nd-use bags. However, customers can grab and give them to the bagger to use for their purchases.
Do you have cases available?
We have cases for most items in stock (water, ice, sodas, seltzers, beers, chips, mixers, etc). You can either ask to add it on for delivery when you check out, or we can bring it to your wagon.
Do you have ice?
We do! They are 8lb bags with handles, or if you need more, we sell them as a pack of 5 for the price of 4 individual bags. These are called Masters of Ice and weigh 40 lbs. We can deliver these masters of ice. However, we cannot deliver individual bags of ice.
When does breakfast stop in the deli?
Breakfast ends at 2 pm every day; it’s when we turn off the grill.
What Happens When we close for the season?
We pack up any non-perishable food and store it in the walk-ins. Each year, any perishable foods (ie, dairy, produce, meat, and anything left on the BOGO shelf ) we donate to a local food pantry in Sayville. This year, we chose St. Ann’s Church and its food pantry. We want to thank anyone who also donated to our food pantry drop bins in the store.